Skip to main content

Table 2 The comparison of the upsampling detection rate results at false positive rate 10−2 except Choi’s method (the false positive rate of Choi’s method 29.2%)

From: Enhanced resampling detection based on image correlation of 3D stereoscopic images

 

Comp.

Scaling factors

  

1.01

1.025

1.05

1.075

1.10

1.15

1.20

1.25

1.30

Proposed

No

90.8

99.4

99.8

99.8

100

100

100

99.8

99.8

 

JPEG100

90.0

98.0

99.8

99.8

100

100

100

100

100

 

JPEG90

72.2

77.0

84.4

81.2

81.6

96.2

92.6

92.2

87.2

Mahdian [4]

No

84.8

91.2

92.4

95.6

98.0

99.8

100

100

100

 

JPEG100

84.4

91.2

92.4

95.2

98.0

99.8

100

100

100

 

JPEG90

76.8

85.2

86.2

88.0

88.8

94.8

93.0

91.8

92.8

Kirchner [7]

No

29.0

90.8

91.4

97.0

98.8

89.2

100

99.8

100

 

JPEG100

27.4

93.8

94.8

98.2

99.4

95.0

100

100

100

 

JPEG90

9.2

75.4

73.4

75.4

69.2

79.6

69.0

75.4

46.4

Choi [14]

No

77.2

80.4

87.9

90.5

90.2

92.0

95.8

96.4

97.5

 

JPEG100

76.6

79.8

87.8

90.6

90.2

92.2

95.9

96.8

97.6

 

JPEG90

60.8

71.3

82.9

83.8

85.2

86.3

88.4

88.2

86.3