Skip to main content

Table 7 SROCC valuse of IQA indices for each type of distortions in TID2013 and TID2008

From: Image decomposition-based structural similarity index for image quality assessment

 

Dis.Type

VIF

GSM

PSNR

VSNR

SSIM

MSSSIM

IWSSIM

RFSIM

FSIM

FSIMc

SFF

IDSSIM

IDSSIMc

TID 2013

AGN

0.8996

0.9063

0.9338

0.8270

0.8687

0.8663

0.8448

0.8877

0.8984

0.9115

0.9070

0.8981

0.9264

 

ANC

0.8428

0.8175

0.8667

0.7266

0.7726

0.7729

0.7514

0.8476

0.8207

0.8536

0.8166

0.8316

0.8496

 

SCN

0.8835

0.9158

0.9245

0.8024

0.8515

0.8543

0.8166

0.8821

0.8749

0.8905

0.8998

0.8822

0.9129

 

MN

0.8449

0.7292

0.8355

0.7118

0.7766

0.8074

0.8019

0.8366

0.7943

0.8093

0.8184

0.8233

0.8188

 

HFN

0.8972

0.8869

0.9182

0.8566

0.8633

0.8648

0.8589

0.9145

0.8991

0.9058

0.9066

0.9000

0.9099

 

IN

0.8536

0.7964

0.9000

0.7343

0.7503

0.7628

0.7281

0.9062

0.8072

0.8250

0.7870

0.8595

0.8541

 

QN

0.8161

0.8841

0.8754

0.8356

0.8657

0.8705

0.8467

0.8968

0.8719

0.8806

0.8638

0.8462

0.8838

 

GB

0.9649

0.9689

0.9102

0.9469

0.9667

0.9672

0.9701

0.9697

0.9550

0.9550

0.9674

0.9692

0.9630

 

DEN

0.9064

0.9432

0.9503

0.9104

0.9254

0.9267

0.9152

0.9359

0.9301

0.9330

0.9090

0.9405

0.9456

 

JPEG

0.9191

0.9284

0.9217

0.9007

0.9200

0.9265

0.9197

0.9398

0.9378

0.9386

0.9272

0.9414

0.9493

 

JP2K

0.9516

0.9601

0.8858

0.9273

0.9468

0.9504

0.9506

0.9518

0.9576

0.9588

0.9575

0.9589

0.9645

 

JGTE

0.8441

0.8512

0.8060

0.8181

0.8493

0.8475

0.8387

0.8786

0.8463

0.8610

0.8830

0.8655

0.8709

 

J2TE

0.8760

0.9181

0.8905

0.8407

0.8828

0.8888

0.8656

0.9102

0.8912

0.8918

0.8707

0.9045

0.9062

 

NEPN

0.7719

0.8130

0.6791

0.6652

0.7821

0.7968

0.8010

0.7704

0.7917

0.7936

0.7667

0.7470

0.7830

 

Block

0.5306

0.6418

0.3297

0.1771

0.5720

0.4800

0.3716

0.0338

0.5489

0.5531

0.1785

0.5292

0.4266

 

MS

0.6275

0.7874

0.7571

0.3632

0.7751

0.7906

0.7833

0.5547

0.7530

0.7486

0.6653

0.6626

0.6994

 

CTC

0.8523

0.4856

0.4466

0.3319

0.4314

0.4633

0.4592

0.5591

0.4686

0.4755

0.4902

0.4858

0.4713

 

CCS

0.3099

0.3573

0.6388

0.3676

0.4141

0.4099

0.4196

0.0204

0.2748

0.8358

0.8268

0.6690

0.8385

 

MGN

0.8466

0.8347

0.8831

0.7644

0.7803

0.7785

0.7727

0.8487

0.8469

0.8569

0.8434

0.8788

0.8813

 

CN

0.8948

0.9124

0.8413

0.8690

0.8565

0.8527

0.8761

0.8917

0.9120

0.9135

0.9007

0.9051

0.9188

 

LCNI

0.9229

0.9562

0.9155

0.8821

0.9057

0.9067

0.9037

0.9009

0.9466

0.9485

0.9261

0.8988

0.9391

 

LCQD

0.8463

0.8972

0.9201

0.8695

0.8542

0.8554

0.8401

0.8959

0.8759

0.8815

0.8794

0.8890

0.8963

 

CHA

0.8848

0.8822

0.8797

0.8644

0.8774

0.8784

0.8681

0.8990

0.8714

0.8925

0.8788

0.8927

0.8870

 

SSR

0.9371

0.9667

0.9108

0.9364

0.9460

0.9482

0.9474

0.9325

0.9564

0.9576

0.9536

0.9536

0.9621

TID 2008

AGN

0.8838

0.8606

0.9070

0.7727

0.8106

0.8085

0.7869

0.8415

0.8566

0.8758

0.8731

0.8501

0.8974

 

ANC

0.8750

0.8090

0.8994

0.7793

0.8029

0.8053

0.7920

0.8621

0.8527

0.8930

0.8625

0.8595

0.8821

 

SCN

0.8709

0.8941

0.9169

0.7664

0.8143

0.8209

0.7713

0.8475

0.8486

0.8718

0.8951

0.8653

0.9074

 

MN

0.8683

0.7452

0.8515

0.7294

0.7794

0.8106

0.8088

0.8533

0.8021

0.8263

0.8365

0.8523

0.8455

 

HFN

0.9074

0.8945

0.9270

0.8800

0.8773

0.8733

0.8702

0.9181

0.9152

0.9233

0.9187

0.9091

0.9100

 

IN

0.8464

0.7234

0.8723

0.6471

0.6732

0.6907

0.6464

0.8805

0.7452

0.7719

0.7483

0.8074

0.8141

 

QN

0.8816

0.8799

0.8696

0.8261

0.8530

0.8588

0.8176

0.8950

0.8564

0.8725

0.8471

0.8481

0.8869

 

GB

0.9540

0.9599

0.8684

0.9330

0.9544

0.9563

0.9636

0.9408

0.9471

0.9471

0.9623

0.9574

0.9529

 

DEN

0.9182

0.9724

0.9416

0.9299

0.9529

0.9582

0.9473

0.9399

0.9602

0.9618

0.9383

0.9539

0.9657

 

JPEG

0.9167

0.9393

0.8717

0.9174

0.9251

0.9321

0.9208

0.9385

0.9369

0.9385

0.9322

0.9438

0.9571

 

JP2K

0.9709

0.9761

0.8131

0.9515

0.9629

0.9699

0.9738

0.9487

0.9773

0.9780

0.9764

0.9694

0.9765

 

JGTE

0.8585

0.8790

0.7565

0.8113

0.8677

0.8680

0.8588

0.8534

0.8707

0.8756

0.8567

0.8701

0.8861

 

J2TE

0.8500

0.8935

0.8308

0.7909

0.8576

0.8606

0.8202

0.8591

0.8543

0.8554

0.8385

0.8602

0.8680

 

NEPN

0.7619

0.7386

0.5814

0.5715

0.7107

0.7376

0.7724

0.7274

0.7491

0.7514

0.6969

0.6824

0.7415

 

Block

0.8320

0.8862

0.6192

0.1926

0.8462

0.7557

0.7623

0.6258

0.8493

0.8470

0.5368

0.7520

0.7811

 

MS

0.5095

0.7190

0.7107

0.3714

0.7230

0.7336

0.7066

0.4335

0.6720

0.6553

0.5224

0.5514

0.5902

 

CTC

0.8403

0.6691

0.6042

0.4746

0.4411

0.6380

0.6301

0.5431

0.6481

0.6509

0.4635

0.6459

0.6629

  1. The top 3 indices are highlighted in italics