Skip to main content

Table 1 Overview of the results

From: Comparison of two 3D tracking paradigms for freely flying insects

 

General

Long term

High density

(N,T)

 

(10,1000)

(20,1000)

(30,1000)

(40,1000)

(50,1000)

(50,3000)

(100,200)

(150,150)

(200,150)

Occlusions

Absolute

21

119

289

846

1248

3,295

889

1,850

3,423

 

Relative

0.007

0.04

0.096

0.282

0.416

0.366

1.482

4.111

7.607

max|C|

Gibbs

102

19,024

1,629

| S P |

| S P |

| S P |

| S P |

| S P |

| S P |

 

Greedy PC

94

2,140

194

516

713

1,928

16,343

9,946

13,413

Time

TbM

27.68

38.22

48.26

65.61

78.63

170.4

34.07

50.59

71.0

 

Gibbs

93.7

3,828.6

1,069.9

530.8

712.8

>4 h

>4 h

>4 h

>4 h

 

Greedy PC

71.1

87.6

110.8

160.2

200.6

748.4

2,560.49

401.56

3,114.2

E ca

TbM

0.009

0.052

0.33

0.326

0.544

0.591

1.16

3.3533

6.7267

 

Gibbs

0.085

1.657

0.791

0.317

2.517

n/a

n/a

n/a

n/a

 

Greedy PC

0.0

0.007

0.012

0.028

0.117

1.6947

0.835

4.5333

12.32

Missing

TbM

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

 

Gibbs

0

0

0

2

7

n/a

n/a

n/a

n/a

 

Greedy PC

0

0

0

0

1

1

0

24

32

Number of tracks

TbM

12

24

40

65

75

137

124

194

284

 

Gibbs

10

20

30

38

43

n/a

n/a

n/a

n/a

 

Greedy PC

10

20

30

40

49

50

106

137

179

  1. The measurements are classified into general, long-term, and high-density results. Each experiment was done for N targets and T frames (second row). Occlusions are given in the third row: the absolute numbers sum all occlusions in all views, and relative occlusions indicate the mean number of occlusions per camera and frame. In row max|C|, the size of the biggest cluster in S P (without PC) and S P (with PC) is given for Gibbs and Greedy PC, respectively. | S P | indicates only one cluster C ( t - δ : t ) , ν = C T , N including all sequences of configurations. Time measurements are given in seconds, besides the entries >4 h highlighting computational time longer than 4 h. Since we focus on biological applicability, we do not discuss tracking results with a computational time >4 h (entries are marked by n/a). In the last row, theE ca measurements are given in combination with the missing flies and the absolute number of calculated tracks.